Closing ceremony of the Tany Vao 2022 summer school in Madagascar. PAIRES is a partnership between AFD and the French National Research Institute for Sustainable Development (IRD) that funds a series of impact assessments of development interventions supported by AFD, with a focus on research from the Global South. Context
Impact assessments aim to provide information on the effectiveness of projects in producing concrete development results. Specifically, the objective is to estimate whether the effect observed following an intervention is actually attributable to that intervention, and to what extent. To do this, assessments rigorously measure the effects of interventions using quantitative, qualitative, geospatial, or mixed method.
With the aim of strengthening research skills and practices in the Global South in the field of impact evaluation, enriching dialogue with public authorities and stakeholders on development projects, and fostering academic debate on key development issues, a partnership between the French National Research Institute for Sustainable Development (IRD) and AFD was established in 2020 to identify and implement a series of impact evaluations of interventions supported by AFD. The IRD provides the expertise, networks, and operational capacity to carry out these evaluations with partners in the Global South. The partnership was extended in October 2024, which will allow for the selection of new projects for evaluation.
This project takes place in a context when there are growing expectations for evaluations that provide a better understanding and measurement of the results and impacts of development interventions. It contributes to meet these expectations in the same way as other types of evaluation, particularly project evaluations carried out by French cooperation actors.
The IRD is recognized for its scientific excellence, its multidisciplinary approach, its experience in conducting impact evaluation, and its local presence, which enables it to develop close ties with university teams and national statistical institutes in the South with which it can collaborate. This collaboration is also part of a shared research agenda and is covered by an institutional partnership between AFD and the IRD.
See also : Assessing the impact of development projects: AFD and IRD extend their PAIRES partnership, in French
Objectives
The PAIRES program funds impact evaluations of development projects financed by AFD Group, with three objectives:
- To enrich dialogue with public authorities and stakeholders on development projects and their results;
- To strengthen the role, skills, and practice of research in the South in the field of impact evaluation;
- To foster academic debate on key development issues.
Method
Impact evaluations use methods derived from social science research to identify and measure the effects that are strictly attributable to an intervention. Quantitative methods generally involve comparing changes in the situation of the population benefiting from the intervention with those of a population that has not been exposed to the intervention but is comparable to the beneficiary population. Impact evaluation, generally using counterfactuals, therefore makes it possible to isolate the causal effect of an intervention on a variable of interest and to quantify that effect.
Beyond promoting impact evaluations, the PAIRES partnership promotes multidisciplinary evaluations, combining quantitative and qualitative methodologies in order to strengthen the lessons learned about the mechanisms underlying change (or the absence of change).
In addition, the PAIRES program involves researchers from the countries of intervention in all its studies to ensure that the specificities of each context are taken into account and with a view to capacity building.
Results
During its first five years of implementation, PAIRES has mobilized six French research laboratories and eight laboratories in the Southern countries concerned. A total of eight impact evaluations, seven feasibility studies, and four training courses have been funded since the project began.
The ongoing impact evaluations cover 11 countries and various sectors (health, energy, biodiversity, education, gender equality, microfinance, agriculture). They have enabled collaboration with several academic, public, and civil society institutions in France and in countries of the Global South. Other assessments are currently being identified.
In terms of capacity building, PAIRES has organized a summer school and two training courses in geospatial impact evaluation in Madagascar. The program has also funded two joint doctoral contracts between the University of Antananarivo and Paris Saclay University for the BETSAKA project.
Lessons learned from impact assessments
Find below the publications and blog articles related to the impact assessments funded under the PAIRES partnership.
The REDGAS assessment aimed to quantify the health, economic, and social impacts of access to gas cooking for households in Burkina Faso.
Publications :
- REDGAS : Retours sur l’enquête de situation de référence
- Mesures de l’exposition des personnes aux particules fines par méthode gravimétrique dans le cadre de l’étude REDGAS
- Pollution de l’air et consommation de bois au Burkina Faso
- Se baser sur le terrain pour mieux cibler l’intervention : Une étude socioanthropologique en baseline
- Seroprevalence and risk factors for SARS-CoV-2 infection in middle-sized cities of Burkina Faso: A descriptive cross-sectional study
- Reducing Pollution from Cooking Smoke: key lessons from the REDGAS randomized study in Burkina Faso
- Présentation du projet et de ses résultats
- Clean Cooking: Insights from two new AFD and FID Experiments
Do forest management plans contribute to promoting the sustainable use of forest resources in the Congo Basin?
Publications :
- Impact Evaluation Study of Forest Management Systems on the Forest Cover in the Congo Basin
- Do forest-management plans and FSC certification help avoid deforestation in the Congo Basin?
- Focus : Plans d’aménagement forestier et conditions de vie des populations des forêts d’Afrique centrale
- Plans d'aménagement forestier et conditions de vie des populations des forêts d'Afrique centrale : une revue de la littérature
The BETSAKA project (Biodiversity-economic tradeoff and synergy assessments for conservation areas): what are the environmental and socioeconomic impacts of terrestrial protected areas in Madagascar from 2000 to 2024?
Publications :
What has been the impact of the Health Voucher on the use of maternal health services by pregnant women in Cameroon?
Publications :
- Coming soon
What is the impact of a parenting education program on children's cognitive and non-cognitive development?
Publications :
What is the impact of viewing awareness videos on domestic violence on knowledge, attitudes, and reporting of domestic violence?
Publications :
How does education through sport help transform gender attitudes and behaviors among middle school students?
Publications :
Contacts :
- Flore Gubert, IRD Scientific Coordinator
- Ingrid Dallmann, AFD Project Manager
- Juliette Maunoury, IRD PAIRES Project Coordinator
ESTEEM Cambodia is more than just a modeling exercise. It is a dynamic macroeconomic tool designed to help Cambodian policymakers make informed decisions in real time and plan for a fair and sustainable green transition. By linking energy, fiscal, and social dimensions, the project supports the government in identifying and managing the economic and structural risks of the low-carbon transition.
Context
Since achieving peace in the early 1990s, Cambodia has undergone rapid economic growth driven by the garment, tourism, and construction sectors. The country is expected to graduate from least developed country status by 2030. This shift from agriculture to manufacturing has led not to more jobs, but to different ones, increasingly formal and urban, contributing to poverty reduction, while also deepening Cambodia’s dependence on fossil fuels and imported electricity.
To sustain growth while pursuing its climate ambitions, the Royal Government of Cambodia has outlined clear strategies for a low-carbon transition. This transformation, however, also brings new macroeconomic and fiscal challenges, against the backdrop of rising energy demand, external trade vulnerabilities, and pressures on public finances. Understanding these challenges and how they interact is essential to design a feasible and financially viable strategy for the energy transition.
Objectives
The ESTEEM Cambodia project supports the Cambodian government in preparing a feasible and financially viable strategy for the country’s energy transition. Through macro-economic modelling activities, it aims to:
- Identify macroeconomic risks that could arise during the shift to cleaner energy, such as on public debt, employment, income inequality and monetary stability.
- Explore how different energy scenarios interact with the overall economy.
To achieve this, research teams based in Paris and in Phnom Penh are designing a macroeconomic model tailored to Cambodia’s economy. They are working closely with key ministries to make sure the model becomes an effective tool for strategic planning. This will help policymakers, especially the Ministry of Economy and Finance, make informed decisions and design a long-term strategy towards carbon neutrality.
WHAT IS ESTEEM?
The ESTEEM Cambodia model is an adaptation of the ESTEEM model developed by AFD.
This model helps identify the transition risks faced by developing economies, allowing policymakers to anticipate these risks and to design a transition trajectory tailored to each country’s specific context.
Method
The ESTEEM Cambodia project marks the second phase of a collaboration between the Royal Government of Cambodia and AFD. It builds on the results of a first phase, which created a user-friendly energy model called CEPIA, designed for the Cambodian energy sector. Developed with iED Consult for the Ministry of Mines and Energy, CEPIA produced four energy scenarios based on the Royal Government’s development and climate action plans.
In phase 2, CEPIA will be linked to the ESTEEM model, in order to study the macroeconomic impacts of the four energy scenarios and connect them with broader socio-economic goals (GDP growth, investment, job creation…).
The project is carried out jointly by AFD researchers, Université Grenoble Alpes, and iED Consult, in close collaboration with the Ministry of Economy and Finance. Key members from various local ministries are actively involved in the development of the model, as well as in workshops and training activities, helping to build local expertise in macroeconomic modelling.
Expected results
The project will result in:
- An ESTEEM macroeconomic model adapted to Cambodia, incorporating the energy scenarios from the CEPIA model developed during Phase I.
- A set of simulations analyzing the macroeconomic implications of Cambodia’s four energy transition scenarios.
- An interactive tool that can be used by government officials to simulate different scenarios and policies, particularly related to the energy transition.
Contact
- Guilherme MAGACHO, AFD
- Isabelle FERAUDO, Université Grenoble Alpes
- Gaëlle LE TREUT, AFD
- Seav Er HUY, AFD Phnom Penh
- Somalyneth SARBOEUN, AFD Phnom Penh